You spend $1,000 on Google Ads. You get 10 phone calls. But which keyword triggered the call? Was it "Emergency Plumber" or "Cheap Plumbing"?
Google Analytics 4 (GA4) won't tell you. It anonymizes everything.
WhatConverts solves this by capturing every single lead (Call, Form, Chat) and tying it back to the exact traffic source, campaign, and keyword. It gives you names, not just numbers. But how does it stack up against CallRail? In this WhatConverts review, we set up tracking for a local service business to find the truth.
Quick Summary
The Agency's Secret Weapon
If you manage ads for clients, WhatConverts is mandatory. It proves your worth. You can show a client a list of 50 names and say, "We generated these leads." Unlike CallRail, which focuses heavily on phones, WhatConverts treats Forms and Chats as equal citizens, making it the ultimate "All-in-One" lead tracker.
Start Your 14-Day Free Trial →
What WhatConverts Actually Does
It sits between your website and your CRM.
When a visitor lands on your site, WhatConverts swaps your phone number with a "Tracking Number" (DNI). If they call, WhatConverts records the call, identifies the caller's name/location, and logs *how* they found you (e.g., Google Ads > Campaign A > Keyword B). It does the same for contact forms and web chats.
Core Features
How to Use WhatConverts — Workflow
We set this up for a hypothetical "Roofing Company" to track Google Ads performance.
- The Setup: We installed the WhatConverts script on the WordPress site.
- The Number: We created a "Dynamic Number Pool" for Google Ads traffic.
- The Test: We clicked a Google Ad (simulated) and called the number on the screen.
- The Result: The phone rang. Inside the WhatConverts dashboard, we saw: "Caller: John Doe", "Source: Google / CPC", "Keyword: Emergency Roof Repair". The audio recording was attached.
Example Use Cases
Who WhatConverts Is Best For
- Marketing Agencies: The reporting features are superior to almost anything else on the market.
- Data-Driven Founders: If you obsess over CAC (Customer Acquisition Cost), you need this data.
- High-Ticket Services: If one lead is worth $1,000+, you can't afford to lose track of where it came from.
Who Should Avoid WhatConverts
- E-commerce Stores: If you sell $20 t-shirts online, you don't need call tracking. Stick to GA4/Shopify analytics.
- Zero Budget: It starts around $30/mo. If you have no marketing budget, stick to free tools.
Pricing & Plans
WhatConverts has a simple pricing model compared to the confusing "minute usage" tiers of competitors.
| Plan | Price (Approx) | Includes |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | ~$30 /mo | All tracking features (Call, Form, Chat) |
| Agency | ~$50 /mo | White-label reporting + Client accounts |
| Usage | Pay-as-you-go | Local numbers are ~$1.50/mo + minutes |
How WhatConverts Compares (vs CallRail)
| Feature | WhatConverts | CallRail | CallTrackingMetrics |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interface | Clean / Modern | Complex | Very Complex |
| Form Tracking | Built-in (Excellent) | Add-on / Basic | Good |
| Reporting | Lead-Centric | Call-Centric | Contact Center |
| Pricing | Simple | Tiered | Expensive |
Limitations & Reality Check
- No Outbound Dialer: Unlike CallRail (Lead Center), WhatConverts is purely for *inbound* tracking. You cannot use it as a softphone to make outbound sales calls easily.
- Porting Numbers: Moving existing phone numbers into any tracking software can take 2-4 weeks. This is an industry-wide issue, but still annoying.
Best Practices: "Mark as Quotable"
Don't just count leads; qualify them.
Pros & Cons
- Captures *every* lead type (Call, Form, Chat) in one view.
- "Lead Detail" view gives complete context (IP, OS, Page).
- Setup is much faster than competitors.
- Agency white-labeling is fantastic.
- No outbound calling/softphone features.
- Usage fees apply for minutes (standard in industry).
- Integrations library is slightly smaller than Zapier's.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does it slow down my website?
No. The WhatConverts script loads asynchronously, meaning it won't block your page content from loading. It is very lightweight.
Can I keep my current phone number?
Yes. You can either port your number in (takes time) or simply forward the WhatConverts tracking numbers to your existing business line.
Is it better than CallRail?
For agencies who want clear reporting on ALL leads (forms + calls), yes. CallRail is better if you need a softphone dialer for your sales team.
Does it integrate with Hubspot?
Yes, it has native integrations for HubSpot, Salesforce, Zoho, and many others via Zapier.
Final Verdict
If you are running paid ads without call tracking, you are burning money. WhatConverts is the most user-friendly, data-rich platform for agencies and service businesses.
It doesn't try to be a phone system (like CallRail); it tries to be a Lead Intelligence System. And at that, it is the best in the world.
See Your Leads in Real-Time →
