Inventory is the enemy of profit. You buy 100 t-shirts, sell 20, and the rest sit in your garage collecting dust.
Printify claims to offer the lowest prices in the industry, especially if you pay for their Premium subscription. But does the math actually hold up when you add shipping and taxes? In this Printify review, we ordered samples to test the "passive income" dream and crunched the real profit numbers.
Quick Summary
The "Amazon" of Custom Printing
Printify is not a printer; it is a network. It connects you to over 80 print providers (like Monster Digital and SwiftPOD). This competition drives prices down, giving you significantly higher profit margins than Printful. If you want to make money, use Printify.
Start Your Free Store →
What Printify Actually Does
Think of Printify as the "Uber" for printing. Uber doesn't own cars; Printify doesn't own printers.
You upload your design (e.g., a logo) to a T-shirt on Printify. You sync it to your Shopify or Etsy store. When a customer buys it for $30, Printify automatically routes the order to a print shop (e.g., in Texas), pays them $12, and you keep the $18 profit. You never touch the product.
Core Features
How to Use Printify — Workflow
We tested the workflow by creating a "Developer Merch" item for TrakSource: A coffee mug that says "Syntax Error: Caffeine Low."
- The Product: We selected the "Accent Mug" (11oz) from the catalog.
- The Provider: We chose "District Photo" as the provider because they had the lowest price and good ratings.
- The Design: We uploaded our PNG logo. The Mockup Generator showed us exactly how it would look in 3D.
- The Test: We ordered a sample. It arrived 5 days later. The print was sharp, dishwasher safe, and the ceramic felt high quality. Total cost to us: ~$6.50 (including shipping).
Example Use Cases
Who Printify Is Best For
- Profit Maximizers: Printify generally offers lower base costs than Printful, meaning more money in your pocket.
- Global Sellers: With providers in the US, UK, Europe, Australia, and China, you can ship locally anywhere.
- Risk-Averse Founders: You pay nothing until you make a sale. It is the ultimate low-risk business.
Who Should Avoid Printify
- Branding Perfectionists: Because there are many different print shops, consistency can vary slightly. Printful is better for 100% identical consistency.
- Custom Packaging: If you want custom branded boxes and tissue paper, Printify's options are limited compared to private suppliers.
Pricing & Real Profit Margins
We ordered a sample mug to verify the real costs. Here is the exact breakdown for the "Accent Mug" (11oz) via District Photo (US Provider).
| Expense Item | Cost (Free Plan) | Cost (Premium) |
|---|---|---|
| Product Base Cost | $5.75 | $4.42 |
| US Shipping | $6.29 | $6.29 |
| Total Cost to You | $12.04 | $10.71 |
| Retail Price (Etsy) | $19.99 | $19.99 |
| Your Profit | $7.95 | $9.28 |
- Connect up to 5 stores
- Unlimited Product Designs
- Standard Product Costs
- Perfect for starting out
- ~20% Discount on Products
- Connect up to 10 stores
- Break-Even: ~15 sales/month
How Printify Compares (vs Printful)
| Feature | Printify | Printful | Teespring |
|---|---|---|---|
| Business Model | Network (Cheaper) | In-House (Pricier) | Marketplace |
| Avg Shirt Cost | $9 - $12 | $13 - $16 | $15+ |
| Production Time | Fast (Distributed) | Medium | Slow |
| Profit Margin | High | Medium | Low |
Limitations & Reality Check
- Provider Variance: A "Bella+Canvas 3001" shirt printed by *Monster Digital* might look slightly different than one printed by *SwiftPOD*. It is crucial to pick a high-rated provider and stick with them.
- Support: Since Printify is a middleman, if a package gets lost, they have to contact the print shop to resolve it. This adds a layer of communication delay.
Best Practices: "The Sample Rule"
Never sell a product you haven't held in your hands.
Pros & Cons
- Lowest base costs in the industry = Higher Profit.
- Network of providers means items rarely go out of stock.
- Premium plan ($24.99) boosts margins significantly.
- Integrates flawlessly with Shopify and Etsy.
- Quality consistency depends on the specific provider.
- Limited custom packaging options compared to Printful.
- Returns are only accepted for defects, not size exchanges.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Printify free?
Yes, the platform is free to use. You only pay for the products when you make a sale.
Is it better than Printful?
Printify is cheaper and offers better margins. Printful offers slightly better consistency and branding options.
Does it work with Etsy?
Yes. Printify has a native Etsy integration. When you publish a product in Printify, it automatically creates the listing in Etsy with photos and descriptions.
How long does shipping take?
Domestic shipping in the US usually takes 2-5 business days. Production takes 1-3 days. So, customers typically receive their order in about a week.
Is the Premium plan worth it?
Yes, if you sell more than 15 items per month. The 20% discount on product costs offsets the $24.99 monthly fee, increasing your profit per sale.
Final Verdict
If you want to start a side hustle or add a merch line to your business, Printify is the logical choice.
The math is simple: It offers the widest selection at the lowest price. While Printful offers a slightly more "premium" unboxing experience, Printify offers the profit margins you need to actually grow a business.
Launch Your Store for Free →
